Having been presenting now for 3 full years as a woman, and 1 year post-operatively having my body surgically aligned as close as I can ever appear to be a natal woman - I have noticed a behavior in the general public, that, I couldn’t quite understand… until now.I think the problem with some, is that, sometimes, in trying to understanding me, and people like me, they have categorize me before giving me a chance and sampling the goods. I feel like I’m seen as nothing more than “waxed fruit” -- a mere prop -- beautiful on the surface, but with no real value, other than allowing it to fill a space in the background – accepting it’s not real, but still with a small purpose of reminding someone of what the “real” bowl of fruit once looked and tasted like.
I can’t justify how “female” I am on a day to day basis, because honestly, being female is an “identity thing”– not a hobby or physical thing. I think that idea gets lost among all the surface changes one goes through in a transition. People see you as selfish and self centered because you must take so many liberties to free yourself from a prison within your body. Someone very close to me recently said “…on the outside, you look the part – but on the inside, you’ll never know what it means to [be] or how a real female thinks”. I acknowledge that, and the fact they'll never understand what it means to be Trans. However, I never said I did know these things – only that I will spend the rest of my life living as close to that narrative as possible. It is YOU who are trying to hold me to some standard (again). That standard being a binary system of what a man and woman is or should be to themselves and in their approach to the world.
I won’t spend my life emulating or “femulating” what I think a woman is – because that would be making this transition “all about them” - rather, trying to satisfy what “they” expect of me. All my life I have felt a built in sense of being a failure. I spent years trying to live up to others expectations of what they thought I should be doing with my life – whether they seen it or not. I did everything I could to compartmentalize the feelings I had of being “girlie” into a closet of shame and denial for so long to protect others (not myself), that, when my own body betrayed me by changing my hormone balance, I felt betrayed when those around me pushed me away when I needed them most to understand and help me.
People will argue that transitioning was a choice. This statement [in its self] is selfish of others to say, because it unfairly glosses over so many other things to bring the conversation back full circle to “their” point, that, “I am a failure because I couldn’t live up to their expectations of what they believe is normal and a good life for me and my kids”. Talk about selfish and self centered?! If only they would take time to understand “My” point of view, and understand, “this is NOT about them.” I am sorry it affects others, and that they feel a sense of loss, etc. But again, that’s about them, and something they need to come to terms on because they are grieving a sense of loss on something they thought they had… they grieve a sense of loss on the part I played for them… but now they struggle to find the value of where I will fit into their lives now and how I will fulfill their expectations of what they want me to do FOR THEM and for others . I can’t help them with that, except to remain patient and hope for a day when they realize that I am the same person they always loved and liked, only the stationary has changed.
I have forgiven myself for not being perfect, and for those around me who also are not perfect. Letting go of hate, shame and guilt is much harder – but again, I am not perfect either. My surgeries have allowed me to be at peace with the stranger that once looked back at me in the mirror. I no longer feel like I was designed to fail – but the trade for that is failing to live to others expectations. That’s where guilt comes in – and boy oh boy have I carried my loads worth.
So now, I feel like a cornered cat with this ABC special that is coming out. So many people with so many opinions. Some good, some not so much. I’ve been asked, “why did you do it?” The short answer is “education”. I feel that my family will give a good inside to other families of America that #1, maybe going through the same situation, and are not alone. And #2 that may be if they see the crosses my family must carry now because of my situation, people will think twice before judging us, and unduly placing more crosses upon us to carry.
Would I do it again? HECK YES! Being on TV was fun, and YES, I liked the attention too… I am after all, a woman!!! But that wasn’t my motive. It was to bring a spot light onto a situation that is beginning to be all to common. Last year, a close friend of mine committed suicide after succumbing to the pressures of guilt and shame she put on her family from transitioning. These pressures were from outside forces. I hope this special honors her and will show the ones that loved her, or have suffered a similar loss, will inspire them to seek understanding and ground them to the fact that they are not alone.
Everyday people are coming out – and it won’t be long before its common place to see and know someone is trans… look at Chaz Bono! I think Cher and Chaz are awesome for the way they have handled themselves in the public, and in their private life too (what we know of it). I only hope Chaz will use the extra attention to bring awareness and out reach to a wider audience – That’s what I have been trying to do… and if you’re listening Oprah, I’m here! lol
I have dreams for myself and my family. I still want to go to work, raise my kids, love my spouse and fulfill her dreams too – but only with what I have to offer. I won’t be put into anyone’s box anymore and be given a leash into their lives. These are impossible situations that are one sided and I am distancing myself and family from things that are negative or make us feel shameful for who we are. No special invite nights for us, when everyone else is celebrating on another night. Instead, I’m surrounding myself with love and those that will support us – not make us feel “different”. My family and I are normal – just a variant of normal.
May be an outsider can’t see this right away for whatever reasons. But if you find yourself looking in, ask yourself, are you judging me by YOUR standards of what a quality life is or should be for me and my family? What makes you right or me right? I don’t feel anyone is wrong for how they feel, until they lay those feelings on top me as what should be my own. I am no less a human or worthy of love and peace than the next person, no matter who they pray to or who they love or how they look, or where they come from. What don’t we get? If I am selfish for being THAT, then call me selfish… but I tend to feel that others are selfish for holding me to their brand and calling me crazy if I don’t float like everyone else.
If you find yourself in these situations, no matter the side of the fence your on, I would like to invite you to sample this “waxed fruit” -- you may be surprised -- and by all means, feel free to eat me.
Some nice points there, C. My best guess: hold on to your chair, it's gonna be quite a ride next week! (Call me and I'll tell you why.)
ReplyDeleteHeck, even MY wife was checking out the clip being run on ABC already, and she'll be watching too (she doesn't know I know you - yet).
I mostly wanted to just wish you good luck and may you find more blessings as you and the family continue to write a new chapter in life.
You are quite a woman Chloe. Thanks for being so open about your life. You are sort of a trail blazer for me....clearing a path for me. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteI too am looking forward to your TV special...heck, even my mother-in-law Ruthie has been waiting patiently for 2 weeks now!
Re: "you’ll never know what it means to [be] or how a real female thinks"
ReplyDeleteWhat an assinine thing for someone to say! As if their is a fixed female mind, possessed only by humans born with the right chromosomal arrangement.
There is a very broad spectrum of self identity, for both males and females, with many overlapping qualities and characteristics. For anyone to think they have a monopoly on female thought, feelings, and understanding, is just plain stupid, and in a way quite frankly, egotistical. We are who we are, and we don't need to justify ourselves to anyone, male or female.
Chloe, I am extremely proud of you! I only wish I had half of your your courage and determination.
Melissa
I also take issue with the "never knowing how a 'real' female thinks" premise. Since I've started dressing differently, I'm aware of people looking at me & making assessments based on my looks vs who I might be as a person. Every night when I walked to the bus stop after attending my transgender support group, I was acutely aware of how much more vulnerable I would be if I actually looked like woman. My plans for transitioning include buying a car, because I simply wouldn't want to walk down dark streets. I've also met transsexual women who wake up in the morning worrying about their biological clock and having a baby, only to remember, "Oh, yeah, ovaries didn't come with the operation." Since I've realized what all my feminine feelings have been about since childhood, and allowed the woman inside me to step forward, my thoughts and views have been changing and growing. And like Melissa said, there IS no fixed male or female mind. There are so many variables. It's true that I didn't grow up as a girl into womanhood, but at the same time, I never felt altogether male, either.
ReplyDeleteI've been patiently awaiting your Primetime show and will be there on Tuesday night. You've been an inspiration to so many of us.
Love always,
Dana
Hi Chloe,
ReplyDeleteSarcastically speaking:
Yeah, you’re selfish!
Just as selfish as any woman who’d want to be noticed.
Just as selfish as any woman who’d want to be respected.
Just as selfish as any woman who spends money and buys makeup.
Just as selfish as any woman who spends time to put on makeup.
Yeah, just as selfish as any woman who wants to be pretty.
Yeah, you’re self-centered!
Just as self-centered as any woman who’d want to find herself.
Just as self-centered as any woman who’d want to be freed from society’s expectations.
Just as self-centered as any woman who spends money on her friends.
Just as self-centered as any woman who spends time with her friends.
Just as self-centered as any woman who wants a choice.
Yeah, just as self-centered as any woman who wants love.
No Chloe. You can’t know what it’s like to think like a woman…
You have no feelings of insecurity.
You have no feelings of love and desire.
You have no feelings to be accepted and loved.
You have no deep desire for the success of your family and loved ones.
You have no deep desire for life-long, lasting, relationships.
You have no wish for security and happiness—the type that gives you that warm feeling all over—the warm fuzzies; like being cozy in bed on cold winter’s night.
As for me,
I’m trapped!
Not free,
to be who I am.
Not free,
to be who I need to be.
Not free,
to be who I want to be.
I love,
but not loved the way I need to be loved.
I kiss,
and I feel that warm tingling feeling all over, as I go dizzy.
I’m perceived,
but they are so wrong in how they judge me.
I feel for you Chloe. You’re out there for all to see, but I keep myself locked away because I fear. I fear, because despite the way you look and sound, you still have adversity because of who you are. Me, on the other hand, will not look nor sound anything like you. What will they do to me?
Love,
Janice
In my first year of transition God dropped a book in my lap. In it I found myself, my life, and the way I'd been living all the years I was pretending to be someone else to meet their expectations. I couldn't believe it, I re-read it periodically and wonder that it took me so long to find it.
ReplyDeleteIt's called "Life Lessons For Women" and it's one of the popular "Chicken soup for the Soul" books by Stephanie Marston and Jack Canefield. I often joke that it should have been called "The Owner's Manual For A Woman's Soul" instead.
It's a great book, but sometimes, especially the first time, it can be a hard read, because you'll keep saying to yourself, "Yes, I've done that!"
Waxed Fruit my eye. I admit I never knew you back in the day so I only know the woman's whose writing has touched my heart with fellowship, and my soul with light. Old saying: If it walks like a duck, sounds like a duck, and looks like a duck, well then, it's a duck. You are inside and out one of the many wonderful people, women, I've met since my journey began in earnest in '03. I'm glad to see you're not letting the people too wrapped up in themselves get you down.
Hang in there, and I'll be praying some extra for you and your family as you all get thrust into the national spotlight. You're doing great girl!
Chloe my friend, I LOVED this blog!!! I say GOOD FOR YOU for not being anyone but yourself. And who has the right to judge you? Ever? What the hell? No one. No one has that right, except for the big guy upstairs...Unless someone has walked a mile in your shoes, they have no clue. I do have to say, it especially infuriates me when I hear that you have a choice. Yeah, there is NO choice in the matter. The same goes for being a lesbian, gay, etc. You are what you are. Pfft, people really hack me off with that bs. I am PROUD to be your friend and to know you; and hope you hold your head up high for as coming as far as you have!!!
ReplyDeleteChloe, My wife and I watched your TV special the other night. We had a nice long discussion afterward. I hope that what your family did will enlighten other families to examine their attitude toward the TG community.
ReplyDeleteJust so you know...I see NO WAX FRUIT when I look at you and your family. You guys are the real deal. It's amazing to see how you all are coping, learning, and growing in love for one another. Love ya, Suzi
I find it so interesting that GG women will say we will have no idea what it is like to be a REAL woman. I ask them if they themselves know? Then I point out that there are thousands of books out there and they do NOT agree as to what a REAL woman is. Of course they then get mad at me because they are confused too as to what a REAL woman is LOL.
ReplyDeleteI gave up on what a real woman is or is not supposed to be and instead "invented" my own ideals. I did this simply by looking at the type of woman I was attracted to. By doing this I found out that the real me was attracted to them not because I was a horny lascivious man, but instead because they were the 'type' I longed to become myself.
In this sense, like attracted like.
I seen the show and at least now maybe your family will stop ignoring and hurting you.
Too bad though that you couldn't name their names and say how they treated you. Maybe if THEY were "outed" they would treat you better? LOL I doubt it but hey, we can all dream.
But I think the worse part is that they did not go into more detail about KF. I had taped the show and was able to at least hear the word and google it. This is how I found out I may have it [along with all the other fun things I have lol].
Just so you know. The show has helped me to deal with a lot of stuff I had going on as a kid. Thanks Chloe.
Stephenie