Lana Moore
Currently there seems to be quite a lot of negative energy bouncing around the “trans blogosphere.” I’ve been watching and reading with much sadness and disappointment. People seem to have lost their inhibitions to spew into the public arena any old thought that happens to enter their minds. What happened to mature social interaction? Is this how people behave face to face? Of course not, because in an actual encounter, we make eye contact, we collect all the facial expressions and emotion that another radiates to us. So, on line, with the perceived protection of time, distance, and shielding it would seem that essential tenets of human courtesy are missing.What bothers me most, I think, is when I have friends on each side of some of these ad hominem attacks and I know both of these fine people to be mature, caring, and intelligent individuals who have apparently gotten lost in the passion of their debate. I feel as though I must suddenly choose which one to side with. Ultimately, I choose not to take the cheese, lest I get drawn into this lose-lose conundrum. After all, which is more important—being right, or getting it right?
We owe it to the ones who have blazed the trails ahead of us as well as to those who will follow in our paths to listen and dialogue with the level of mutual respect that all human beings deserve. Never before was the axiom “United We Stand, Divided We Fall” more poignant. Look, if we can’t even seem to agree—or at least be civil in our disagreements—how can we ever expect to make any inroads with regards to changing the hearts and minds of the “mainstream?”
Another phenomenon I am also seeing is something a friend recently described to me as “Crab Mentality.” This describes a way of thinking best described by the phrase "if I can't have it, neither should you." The metaphor refers to a pot of crabs, individually the crabs could escape from the pot, but instead, they grab at each other in a useless "king of the hill" competition (or sabotage) which prevents any from escaping and ensures their collective demise.
The analogy in human behavior is that of a group that will attempt to "pull down" (negate or diminish the importance of) any member who achieves success beyond the others, out of jealousy, conspiracy or competitive feelings.
This term is associated with short-sighted, non-constructive thinking rather than a unified, long-term, constructive mentality. It is also used colloquially in reference to individuals or communities attempting to "escape" a so-called "underprivileged life", but kept from doing so by others attempting to ride upon their coat-tails or those who simply resent their success."
My partner, Chloe has become a lightening rod for much of the blog negativity. I lost count of the commenters who start by admitting their prejudice, stating that they did not or “could not” even watch her ABC television show and then comes the big BUT, as they go on to ignorantly rip the show and her personally. There is a difference between--an informed questioning and commentary of a person’s perceived motives and/or judgment--and outright pillorying them.
And then there is the whole “Bee Sting” fiasco. It doesn’t help that it has been mischaracterized, or at least presented it in a way that was easily misunderstood, but Chloe has explained it clearly and concisely, more than once. Obviously the bee sting did not “turn her into a woman” but, like Al Gore’s “I invented the internet” misnomer, this is just too irresistible for the “crabs in the pot” to let go of. This has actually become amusing to watch as it takes on a life of its own.
Chloe understands this and she knows all too well that this sort of thing goes with the territory when one puts themselves “out there” the way she has. She can take it. I can say with first hand experience because I know her personally--and obviously I am biased so you may take this for what it is worth--that Chloe is one of the most caring and genuine people I have ever met. She is strong and principled, yet kind and caring. She stands up for what she believes, but will readily admit when she is wrong. Above all, she is human, like you and me, which takes me back to my broader points at the beginning of this piece. Let us not forget our humanity as we navigate and interact within the cold digital social matrix of the internet blogoshpere.
I am also happy to report that for every public harsh negative criticism launched at Chloe, there are probably one hundred messages of gratitude and encouragement received “behind the scenes.” So, it is like I have been telling my children, don’t get sucked into the negativity, sometimes you gotta do what you know is right for you, no matter what others will think or say. Follow what is in your heart because acquiescing to the bullies, only validates their angry cause. Words will only get you so far, it takes action. You must set the example, you must Be The Change you want to see.
~Lana Moore
~Lana Moore
Lana,
ReplyDeleteI am so glad for your guest blog here. With great sadness I have watched a few attempt to tear down many of us who are trying to take this most important step of our lives. Even if these actions are not successful, they are much cause of sadness and distress and all too often drag us back.
The time has come to wish them good circulation pass them by. No relevance for our lives is gained by listening to their anger and vitriol.
I wish you and Chloe all the best
This was very well put Lana. I know Chloe as a genuine and caring soul who is always willing to do so much for others. Unfortunately there is within our community as in any, a certain negative energy which is unfortunately inherrent in the human race. Sometimes I may not agree with someone so I keep my peace. We are all entitled to our own opinions and individuality. I just hope that others will take a moment before making a negative comment about ANYONE and think how it may hurt them.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't have said any of that better myself. I think being true to thine own self and being the change you want to see are definitely two good ways to look at all this and go.
ReplyDeleteWhile this is not the first time, I want to repeat what I have said publicly several times: Those who come before me and lived their lives so that others may peer into them have done me a great service - and Lana - you and Chloe have saved lives. It is a simple fact. I find it appalling how quickly some people run to create chaos or to see only the bad in someone else. I hope one day we can all practice "letting the divine in me see the divine in you."
ReplyDeleteIf I may Lana, what you are seeing online..be it blogs or in chat sites is what...sadly...many of these folks are like. Be it using what can best be called code words to describe what or rather WHO they despise to the point of treating those who are not able to get the SRS or go on HRT due to medical or other reasons as though they are unpersons. Add to this also that the community at large is engaged en masse in reinforcing stereotypes and one has a situation which is rather reprehensible. By the by...it is nothing Chloe or yourself did so let's say that here. it is the behavior of others, which gives license to those who already see this community as being less than human to say 'see we told you so'. The way things are going, it reminds me of the words my neprhologist said several months ago when he mentioned that I still have a level 3 failure...'we cannot reverse what has happened, what needs to happen now it so make sure things do not get any worse'. If one looks around, they will see this point can be applied due to its validity.
ReplyDelete"Negative Energy" can go suck my,,, Oh wait a min,,,
ReplyDeleteIf one isn't free and equal, then nobody is. Equality for all, nothing less will do.
ReplyDeleteAnd they can say what they want and point out and blow out of proportion any personal shortcomings they want, but they can never ever take away the good Chloe has done for her friends and community. And in the end that what really matters. Being kvetchy never really moved anyone or any cause forward.
I, for one, thinks Chloe is a wonderful friend and i feel blessed as having her as a friend. Her site has been a miracle for me. I honestly dont know what I would have done without PINKessence.
ReplyDeleteIf I ever needed Chloe, she always has been there for me.
Well, ya know Lana, the negative judgements one makes about others are often the reflections of one's own negative self judgements.
ReplyDeleteIndeed Sherri!
ReplyDeleteYou both are beautiful, inside and out. I don't care what anyone says. Some people should get off their high horse, before they get thrown. ;)
ReplyDeleteYou're right...Chloe is a lightning rod. However, she is a strong woman, and should expect such strikes. When you deal with hundreds and thousands of people, you can be sure that there will be some that vehemently disagree with you and everything you stand for. I have taken quite a few lightning strikes myself...right here on this site...because I'm very conservative politically. My skin grows thicker day by day, and I'm sure Chloe's will too. It just comes with the territory. You will never get EVERYONE to agree and be united regarding Chloe. She will always be able to garner great strength and encouragement from a loving majority that appreciate her trailblazing leadership and moxy. Who was it that said something like, "life is 10% what you do, and 90% your attitude"? I would never expect everyone to get along with me, but I still love everyone. I have learned not to let our differences get in the way of the fact that we are all humans who deserve to be loved.
ReplyDeleteGreat read and so true of the internet bloggest sphere.And being in the middle of many dialogs becomes very hard in this day and age of polarity Lana.I know how you feel...
ReplyDeleteHugs for you Chloe and Lana.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ellen :)
ReplyDeleteLana, I am glad to be your friend.
ReplyDeleteI've noticed things are getting pretty vicious in all of the blogospheres out there. Sadly the trans blogosphere is no different. Some trans phobic guy came on a Facebook fan page for a young transwoman and started a fight and got steamrolled by about 20 trans people. Although I have to admit, that was pretty funny.
ReplyDeleteI think it's easy for people to be jerks online even if they're perfectly decent people in real life. There's no way to see the emotion of people, and there's the whole anonymity issue.
That sucks that anyone would pick on Chloe. She's one of the big trailblazers in our community. I mean even if people don't agree with what she did, they should respect her for all she's accomplished. And to all of us in the community, she's such an inspiration.and a beacon of hope. Many trans people who don't know about this site at least know who she is.
I agree about Being The Change. I've been making a conscious effort to not be so negative or to judge people. I know as I transition, I'm going to be judged A LOT, so I want to not judge other people. Also, I'm trying to take the word 'hate' out of my lexicon. Like when I say "ugh I hate it when that happens" I'll apologize and rephrase it. I don't want to even use the word at all.
Its sad to see so much division in the trans community at a time when we more then ever need to be unified. I've been working very hard ay Being The Change here in my home state of South Dakota. Because of the rural nature of the state, most of the trans peeps here are in stealth and can't afford to be out. I'm unemployed and partly disabled from a work accident and I was to well known from before I started my transition, so going stealth is not an option for me. I decided to take the risky path of being out and open about being trans and my transition. Its a decision that I do not regret at all. I've been incredibly surprised and rewarded in ways that I would not have believed possible 3 years ago when I started my transition and decided to be out and open about it.
ReplyDeleteAt the urging of my gender therapist, I stated to get involved in local LGBT activism 2 1/2 years ago. I began working behind the scenes for the states LGBT org, EQSD. The work I did, combined with that of others, has helped create several changes for the better here, in particular for trans people. One thing has led to another, and now I find myself in a unique position do much more then I could have dreamed possible for the states trans community. Since the first of the year, things have really started to happen, I've been invited to speak on trans issues four times since the first of the year. The first time was at an affirming church. The second time was at the South Dakota Equality Summit at the state capitol. The third time was at the South Dakota School of Medicine to 80+ first year med students. And the fourth time was this past Sunday at PFLAG meeting of a newly formed group in a college town 70 miles from where I live Sioux Falls.
And now it looks like my work is about to take a much bigger step forward. I'm going to be really sticking my neck out on the next steps I'm about to take. I was recently contacted by the American Civil Liberties Union to meet with 2 of their attorneys to discuss a couple of things that could have a major impact on the trans community here. The first thing was they asked if I would be willing to let the ACLU use me as a test case to try to change the states policies and law for changing the gender markers on drivers licenses and birth certificates. The ACLU will pay for all of the costs to do my legal name change, get a US passport with the gender marker changed and then try to get my gender markers changed on my drivers license and my birth certificate with out having had SRS by taking advantage of the states vague law and policies on this. I signed the retainer agreement and this is now in progress. They warned me that there is a very goof chance that I will end up getting a lot of media attention once we end up in court and that some of it could be very negative up to and including drawing the attention of the Westboro Baptist Church.
The second thing the ACLU attorneys discussed, was to ask if I would be interested in starting a transgender advocacy organization to work in both states of North Dakota and South Dakota. The ACLU is offering to do all the legal work to create this new non profit organization and to provide the seed money needed to get it started. Basically it would provide a formal framework for the advocacy work that I've been doing mostly on my own. This is something that had been thinking about doing for a while, as there is a very real need for such an organization here if we are to ever raise public awareness of trans issues to be able to pass a transgender inclusive state non-discrimination law. I accepted the ACLU's offer and we are now in preliminary discussion on how to structure the organization.
Oh so true dear.
ReplyDeleteStatistically, 80% of communications is non verbal, so even if you are on a phone you are at a huge disadvantage but the internet has removed even more of the non verbal dialogue from our efforts to communicate and so it becomes so difficult to catch the nuances of the conversation and so we oft misinterpret the intent of the comment made or question asked. That said, there have been some comments made that are not open to interpretation and seem to be of a personal threat nature. I do not mind lively debate and as a project manager I have had to deal with written communications and the issues it presents for many years. So I have a tendency to take a moment and reflect before I press submit (there is something about that word that puts me off my feed). Although sometimes I find that I respond out of an emotional need rather than to be helpful to others. It is a difficult thing to reign oneself in but we all need to look hard at what we type in an environment of people who should be standing tall together instead of beating each other down.
Peace and love
Namaste
Bobbi
Great message.
ReplyDeleteThanks Lana and Chloe for putting yourselves out there for us.
-Susan
Love the way you think girl! I pray life is bringing you all you so richly deserve!
ReplyDeletePeace
Shari
Tis a great blog on all levels. The debates that turn into vicious verbal assaults is a problem that our society in general has, just look at our political "dialogue". I suppose it can be even worse in the TG community because so many have so much pent up pain and anger that it spews more freely.
ReplyDeleteJealousy is a big issue as well, and really does no good besides holding the jealous one back. We all struggle with it, but it can cripple people. I've read a lot of the nasty stuff said about Chloe, and it is quite demented, but like it says in this blog, it comes with the territory, unfortunately.
Anyways, good stuff :).
Chloe, you are such an inspiration to me. I have known since I was 4 years old I wanted to be a girl. I always thought as I got older it would go away. But it became stronger and stronger the need to be fully female. That was all I ever idenified with. Like so many transgenderd persons I spent everyday crying and in deep depresion. I need courage oh so much of it because my mind is made up. I am going to transition, there is no choice, I am already a woman, I must take care of the rest to be happy. I look back on my life, all 40 years of it and I wish more than anything i started this road to contentment happiness and satisfaction when i was 19. why oh why did i not do that has haunted me for so so long. I am so incredibly proud of you!!! You truly are my inspiration.
ReplyDeleteLove Ashley:)